Diagnosing a Way Out of Jail Time

I’m doing research on mental health and reading “Is There No Place On Earth For Me?”, a book by Susan Sheehan. I picked it up because it gives an insider look at Creedmoor, a psychiatric hospital in Queens that I passed often on Grand Central Parkway as a child coming back from family visits in the Bronx and Queens.

Aside from main story, an insightful view of the system by following a patient, was an odd story of a New York police officer who shot a 15-year-old black boy in the head after the youth asked him a question. No threat. No gun. No argument. Just asked him a question.

At trial, a defense psychiatrist said the officer had a “psychomotor epilepsy” and had had a seizure during the unprovoked shooting. The officer was acquitted due to “mental disease or defect” and sent to Creedmoor. A year and half later, he was released because the psychiatrists treating him could find nothing wrong with him. Since they could only keep him if he was a danger to himself or others, they had little choice.

After being released, he also tried to get disability from the NYPD, which was denied.

It reminded me of a recent story when a psychologist suggested that a young, drunk man who killed four others might have psychological afflictions because he was too rich to tell right from wrong. He was dubbed the “affluenza teen.” He served two years.

This entry was posted in News and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.